Skip navigation

Comment: Roma people in Europe are vulnerable to poor practice in genetics, analysis reveals

17th November 2021

An analysis of research papers and DNA databases reveals multiple ethical issues with the handling and interpretation of DNA data from Roma people, according to a group of academics including Dr Matthias Wienroth from Northumbria. Writing in this week’s Nature, Veronika Lipphardt, Mihai Surdu, Peter Pfaffelhuber and Nils Ellebrecht from Freiburg University in Germany, Matthias Wienroth from Northumbria University and Gudrun Rappold from Heidelberg University in Germany argue that, “Geneticists in Europe need to face up to the fact that unethical research practices are still happening on home soil — not just on other continents.”

Over five years, Lipphardt and colleagues have investigated five public DNA databases and more than 450 publications to better understand how researchers, from geneticists to molecular anthropologists, have obtained and studied DNA from Roma people — the largest minority group in Europe. The team questioned 10 researchers, 3 ethics committees and 13 research and funding institutions and journal editors about their methods and policies.

The authors flag numerous problems with studies published between 1921 and 2021 (roughly two-thirds of which were published in the past three decades). They highlight issues with consent; with how data have been or are being shared and used, including by law-enforcement agencies; with the language researchers use when describing Roma people; and with methodological approaches and interpretations.

In their view, research and peer-review practices must change, and they advocate four key actions to help resolve the issues. The first is to establish an international oversight board. This would involve human and forensic geneticists, bioethicists, medical scientists, anthropologists and scholars from the social sciences and humanities — as well as community advocates — investigating all the DNA data held in public databases that has been obtained from oppressed groups. It would extend the ethical diligence better established in medical genetics to research on all human genetic data, and could be led by the European Society of Human Genetics, the authors suggest. They also recommend retracting unethical work; improving publication practices; improving scientific training; and encouraging participation from the communities whose DNA might be studied. 

“Given our long history of misrepresenting human genetic variation, these challenges must be met if people’s trust in science, as well as in health care, policing and criminal justice, is to be retained — or, in some cases, restored,” they conclude.

The full article can be viewed here

comments powered by Disqus


a sign in front of a crowd

Northumbria Open Days

Open Days are a great way for you to get a feel of the University, the city of Newcastle upon Tyne and the course(s) you are interested in.

Research at Northumbria

Research at Northumbria

Research is the life blood of a University and at Northumbria University we pride ourselves on research that makes a difference; research that has application and affects people's lives.

NU World

Explore NU World

Find out what life here is all about. From studying to socialising, term time to downtime, we’ve got it covered.

Latest News and Features

Crime scene
Sustainable condenser tumble dryers
View of the countryside from Richmond, London. People on green grass field near lake during daytime
The Crypt at Newcastle Cathedral
Event aims to connect academic knowledge and policy makers
Final year Music Degree students Allan Colver, Jeremy Teasdale and Caitlin Hedley, pictured standing next to a grand piano
BA (Hons) Fine Art student, Sophie Bass preparing for REVEAL.
More events

Upcoming events

Grow Your Own – How To Attract, Develop and Retain a Talented Team.
The Building Safety Act and its Implications

Back to top